Lewis Evans

Lewis Evans
Education:

PhD in Agricultural Economics, Wisconsin, 1976

M.Agr.Sc (Honours 1), Canterbury, 1970

B.Agr.Sc  Canterbury, 1965

Curriculum Vitae: Download Curriculum Vitae 83kB

Research Interests

Theoretical and Applied Microeconomics

Law

Economics

Selected publications

Academic Journal
May
2006
"Incentive Regulation of Prices when Costs are Sunk", Journal of Regulatory Economics 2006. 29(3), 239-264 (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 274kB

We present a model featuring irreversible investment, uncertain future demand and capital prices, and a regulator who sets the firm's output price at discrete intervals.

View full details »

Feb
2005
"Risk, Price Regulation, and Irreversible Investment", International Journal of Industrial Organizations 2005. 23, 109-128 (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 223kB

We show that regulators' price-setting, rate base, and allowed rate of return decisions are inextricably linked.

View full details »

May
2003
"Optimal Price Regulation in a Growth Model with Monopolistic Supplier of Intermediate Goods", Canadian Journal of Economics 2003. 36(2), 463-474 (with Jie Zhang, Neil Quigley)

Jan
1999
"The Ultimatum Game: Optimal Strategies without Fairness", Games and Economic Behavior 1999. 26 (2), 251-252 (with Stephen Burnell, Shuntian Yao)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 185kB

The Ultimatum game is simple and this facilitates its use in the study of predictions of game theory. Experimental evidence suggests that it does not predict individual behavior well, unless individuals gain welfare from fairness in transactions, or have expectations about some wider game. Our model excludes any notion of fairness by including (potential) rivalry in transactions. In this game the proposer's expectations yield outcomes that are consistent with experimental evidence. Offers can be large or small, with none in an intermediate range. The consequent distribution appears in Dictator game experiments. Our model explains how it is generated by expectations.

View full details »

May
1996
"Contracts in Continuous Time Asymmetric Information Models: The Importance of Large Information Flows", Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organisation 1996. 29(3), 523-535 (with William A. Brock)

Jan
1996
"The Economic Efficiency of Telecommunications in a Deregulated Market: the Case of New Zealand", The Economic Record 1996. 72, 24-35 (with David Boles de Boer)

Oct
1995
"Shareholder Liability Regimes, Principal-Agent Relationships and Banking Industry Performance", The Journal of Law and Economics 1995. XXXVIII(2), 497-520 (with Neil Quigley)

May
1994
"On the Restrictive Nature of Constant Elasticity of Demand Functions", International Economic Review 1994. 35(4), 1015-1018

Sep
1989
"The Rational Regulator's Pricing Response to Enhanced Opportunities to Bypass", Journal of Regulatory Economics 1989. September, 271-292 (with Steven Garber)

Jun
1988
"Public Utility Regulators are Only Human: A Positive Theory of Rational Constraints", American Economic Review 1988. 78(3), 444-462 (with Steven Garber)

Other
Jul
2007
"Commodity Price Behavior With Storage Frictions", 2007. (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 607kB

View full details »

Sep
2006
"The Performance Based Research Fund and the Benefits of Competition Between Universities", Evaluating the Performance-Based Research Fund: Framing the Debate (Institute of Policy Studies) , Chapter 9 (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 209kB

In this chapter, we set the competition promoted by the PBRF in context by considering the costs and benefits of competition in the tertiary sector.

View full details »

Jun
2006
"A Dynamic Theory of Cooperatives: The Link between Efficiency and Valuation", Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 2006. 16(2), 364-383 (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 204kB

We show thast if cooperative's shares are priced at the present value of expected dividends and supplier entry and exit decesions are taken solely on the basis of profitability of membership then there is no ineffeciency and we describe a functioning example. Finally, our valuations show that there is no "time horizon" investment problem, at least from an industry prospective.

View full details »

Mar
2006
"Estimating the WACC in a Regulatory Setting: An Assessment of Dr Martin Lally's paper 'The Weighted Average Cost of Capital for Electricity Lines Businesses' of 8 September 2005", 2006. (with Glenn Boyle, Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 650kB

In this paper, we undertake a detailed analysis of the approach followed in LINES. We do so from the perspective of a referee who has been asked to provide a review of that report in order to assess its suitability for publication in an edited book or journal that adheres to conventional academic standards. Although LINES has not, of course, been submitted for publication or
review of this kind, its contents and recommendations should nevertheless meet minimum standards of accuracy, thoroughness and consistency. It is these criteria we use to assess LINES.

View full details »

Dec
2005
"Parallel Importation and Service Quality: An Empirical Investigation of Competition between DVDs and Cinemas in New Zealand", Journal of Competition Law and Economics 2005. 1(4), 747-770 (with Matt Burgess)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 638kB

Investigations into the causes and effects of parallel importing have concentrated on price discrimination, but arbitrage can also occur on non-price dimensions.

View full details »

Oct
2005
"Essays in Water Allocation: The Way Forward", 2005. (with Kevin Counsell)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 1.2MB

In this article we consider the tradeable property rights framework as a method of allocating water. Our objectives are to explain why such an approach can improve aspects of New Zealand's current water allocation framework, to establish the appropriate set of institutional arrangements for a tradeable rights framework to operate effectively, and to examine what may influence the value of tradeable water rights.

View full details »

Feb
2005
"The Efficiency Test under Competition Law and Regulation in Small Distant Open Economy that is New Zealand", New Zealand Economic Papers 2004. 38 (2), 241-264

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 310kB

This paper considers the application of competition law and price regulation in
the very small, and isolated economy that is New Zealand. It argues that the total surplus (efficiency) criterion should be applied in tests of practices and actions where the competition threshold is not met or doubtful. Further, it argues that this criterion is admitted, if not required, under New Zealand statutes. The differential treatment of affected parties, including foreign investors, in measuring the surplus is considered.

View full details »

Nov
2003
"Asset Stranding is Inevitable: Implications for Optimal Regulatory Design", 2003. (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 367kB

We show that when there is a choice between reversible and irreversible technology, there is no price specification under rate of return regulation that will induce the firm to choose the efficient bundle of technology,

View full details »

Mar
2003
"Accident Compensation: The Role of Incentive Consumer Choice and Competition", Victoria University Law Review 2003. 34(3), 423-432 (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 301kB

This paper reviews three of the economic issues raised by the structure of our accident compensation scheme: the role of incentives, the relationship with the broader insurance market and the costs of government monopoly provision.

View full details »

Sep
2002
"The Interaction Between Contract and Competition Law", 2002. (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 184kB

This paper provides some economic perspectives on the interaction between contract law and competition (antitrust) law.

View full details »

Aug
2002
"Efficient Price Regulations of Networks that have Sunk Costs: Should Caps be Based on Historical or Replacement Costs", 2002. (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 3.1MB

This paper examines societal welfare produced by regulated firms that have a
significant proportion of their costs generated by irreversible (sunk) investment.

View full details »

Jan
2002
"Trade Reform in New Zealand: Unilateralism at Work", Relaxed Reciprocity: Historical and Modern Experience with Unilateralism Trade Liberalization 2002. (with Martin Richardson)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 191kB

The aim of this paper is to consider the political forces behind these trade reforms with an eye towards explaining the political success of the unilateral approach.

View full details »

Jan
2001
"The Law and Economic Basis of Enforcement of Governance of Private Joint Venture Network Markets: the case of NZEM", Anti Trust 2001. 3, 611-643 (with Terence Arnold)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 105kB

View full details »

Jan
2000
"The Efficiency of Contractual Arrangements in Private Agricultural Product Markets", Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 2000. 31, 813-846 (with Haleigh Boyd, Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 120kB

In this paper we use examples of contracts between producers and processors in the forestry, wine and processed vegetable markets to consider the extent to which contracts may provide efficient vehicles for the alignment of interests between producers and processors in agricultural markets.

View full details »

Aug
1999
"Economic Measurement and the Authorisation Process: The Expanding Place of Quantitative Analysis", Competition and Consumer Law Journal: A Journal of Trade Practices in Law 1999. 7(2), 99-124

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 165kB

The paper takes the efficiency objective of the authorisation process under the Commerce Act 1986 as given.

View full details »

Jun
1999
"Contracting, Incentives for Breach, and the Impact of Competition", World Competition 2000. 23(2) (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 80kB

In this paper we provide an economic perspective on the application of competition law to contracts.

View full details »

Jan
0001
"The Role and Significance of Cooperatives in New Zealand Agriculture, A Comparative Institutional Analysis", (with Richard Meade)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 1.7MB

A report prepared for the New Zealand Ministry of Agriculture and Finance

View full details »

Working Papers

Jul
2007
"Commodity Price Behavior With Storage Frictions", 2007. (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 607kB

View full details »

Sep
2006
"The Performance Based Research Fund and the Benefits of Competition Between Universities", Evaluating the Performance-Based Research Fund: Framing the Debate (Institute of Policy Studies) , Chapter 9 (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 209kB

In this chapter, we set the competition promoted by the PBRF in context by considering the costs and benefits of competition in the tertiary sector.

View full details »

Jun
2006
"Options Provided by Storage can Explain High Electricity Prices", 2006. (with Kevin Counsell, Graeme Guthrie, Steen Videbeck)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 295kB

We show that a price-taking generator will only generate when the output price exceeds its marginal cost by an amount that reflects the value of the option to delay the use of stored fuel.

View full details »

Jun
2006
"A Dynamic Theory of Cooperatives: The Link between Efficiency and Valuation", Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 2006. 16(2), 364-383 (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 204kB

We show thast if cooperative's shares are priced at the present value of expected dividends and supplier entry and exit decesions are taken solely on the basis of profitability of membership then there is no ineffeciency and we describe a functioning example. Finally, our valuations show that there is no "time horizon" investment problem, at least from an industry prospective.

View full details »

May
2006
"Assessing the Integration of Electricity Markets Using Principal Component Analysis: Network and Market Structure Effects", Contemporary Economic Policy 26,, 145-161 (with Graeme Guthrie, Steen Videbeck)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 1.4MB

We study whether the New Zealand market has been a national market or a set of local markets since its inception in 1996.

View full details »

May
2006
"Incentive Regulation of Prices when Costs are Sunk", Journal of Regulatory Economics 2006. 29(3), 239-264 (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 274kB

We present a model featuring irreversible investment, uncertain future demand and capital prices, and a regulator who sets the firm's output price at discrete intervals.

View full details »

Dec
2005
"Parallel Importation and Service Quality: An Empirical Investigation of Competition between DVDs and Cinemas in New Zealand", Journal of Competition Law and Economics 2005. 1(4), 747-770 (with Matt Burgess)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 638kB

Investigations into the causes and effects of parallel importing have concentrated on price discrimination, but arbitrage can also occur on non-price dimensions.

View full details »

Feb
2005
"The Efficiency Test under Competition Law and Regulation in Small Distant Open Economy that is New Zealand", New Zealand Economic Papers 2004. 38 (2), 241-264

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 310kB

This paper considers the application of competition law and price regulation in
the very small, and isolated economy that is New Zealand. It argues that the total surplus (efficiency) criterion should be applied in tests of practices and actions where the competition threshold is not met or doubtful. Further, it argues that this criterion is admitted, if not required, under New Zealand statutes. The differential treatment of affected parties, including foreign investors, in measuring the surplus is considered.

View full details »

Feb
2005
"Risk, Price Regulation, and Irreversible Investment", International Journal of Industrial Organizations 2005. 23, 109-128 (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 223kB

We show that regulators' price-setting, rate base, and allowed rate of return decisions are inextricably linked.

View full details »

Nov
2003
"Asset Stranding is Inevitable: Implications for Optimal Regulatory Design", 2003. (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 367kB

We show that when there is a choice between reversible and irreversible technology, there is no price specification under rate of return regulation that will induce the firm to choose the efficient bundle of technology,

View full details »

Mar
2003
"Accident Compensation: The Role of Incentive Consumer Choice and Competition", Victoria University Law Review 2003. 34(3), 423-432 (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 301kB

This paper reviews three of the economic issues raised by the structure of our accident compensation scheme: the role of incentives, the relationship with the broader insurance market and the costs of government monopoly provision.

View full details »

Aug
2002
"Efficient Price Regulations of Networks that have Sunk Costs: Should Caps be Based on Historical or Replacement Costs", 2002. (with Graeme Guthrie)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 3.1MB

This paper examines societal welfare produced by regulated firms that have a
significant proportion of their costs generated by irreversible (sunk) investment.

View full details »

Jan
2002
"Trade Reform in New Zealand: Unilateralism at Work", Relaxed Reciprocity: Historical and Modern Experience with Unilateralism Trade Liberalization 2002. (with Martin Richardson)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 191kB

The aim of this paper is to consider the political forces behind these trade reforms with an eye towards explaining the political success of the unilateral approach.

View full details »

Jan
2001
"The Law and Economic Basis of Enforcement of Governance of Private Joint Venture Network Markets: the case of NZEM", Anti Trust 2001. 3, 611-643 (with Terence Arnold)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 105kB

View full details »

May
2000
"Internet Service Providers (ISP) Markets of Australia and New Zealand", Journal of Policy Regulation and Strategy for Telcommunication Information and Media 2000. 2(5), 487-495 (with David Boles de Boer, Christina Enright)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 58kB

This study provides an economic history of the Internet access market in New Zealand from 1996, essentially the inception of the market, to early 1999. It reviews the strategy literature about entry to new markets and tests a resource-based theory concerning the timing of entry.

View full details »

Jan
2000
"The Efficiency of Contractual Arrangements in Private Agricultural Product Markets", Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 2000. 31, 813-846 (with Haleigh Boyd, Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 120kB

In this paper we use examples of contracts between producers and processors in the forestry, wine and processed vegetable markets to consider the extent to which contracts may provide efficient vehicles for the alignment of interests between producers and processors in agricultural markets.

View full details »

Aug
1999
"Economic Measurement and the Authorisation Process: The Expanding Place of Quantitative Analysis", Competition and Consumer Law Journal: A Journal of Trade Practices in Law 1999. 7(2), 99-124

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 165kB

The paper takes the efficiency objective of the authorisation process under the Commerce Act 1986 as given.

View full details »

Jun
1999
"Contracting, Incentives for Breach, and the Impact of Competition", World Competition 2000. 23(2) (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 80kB

In this paper we provide an economic perspective on the application of competition law to contracts.

View full details »

Jan
1999
"The Ultimatum Game: Optimal Strategies without Fairness", Games and Economic Behavior 1999. 26 (2), 251-252 (with Stephen Burnell, Shuntian Yao)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 185kB

The Ultimatum game is simple and this facilitates its use in the study of predictions of game theory. Experimental evidence suggests that it does not predict individual behavior well, unless individuals gain welfare from fairness in transactions, or have expectations about some wider game. Our model excludes any notion of fairness by including (potential) rivalry in transactions. In this game the proposer's expectations yield outcomes that are consistent with experimental evidence. Offers can be large or small, with none in an intermediate range. The consequent distribution appears in Dictator game experiments. Our model explains how it is generated by expectations.

View full details »

Jun
1998
"Money and Medicines: An Economic Analysis of Reference Pricing and Related Public-sector Cost-containment Systems for Pharmaceuticals with Special Reference to New Zealand, by Alan Woodfield, John Fountain and Pim Borren (a review)", NZ Economic Papers 1998. 32, 83-93 (with Neil Quigley)

Filetype IconDownload (PDF) 52kB

View full details »